← Back to Blog

Block Billing on Outside Counsel Invoices: What Gets Missed

A block-billed line hides how the time divided. A clean line-by-line review still cannot show how the work divided across the invoice.

By , Co-founder, LegalOperator ·

What block billing is

Block billing is a single time entry that covers several tasks and gives one total for all of them. Here is an example of a block-billed line: "Prepare for deposition; review produced documents; call with client re strategy. 6.5 hours." The same work billed as three entries would show the time for each task.

The line is not wrong because the total is wrong. It is a problem because the total cannot be tested. Nobody outside the firm can tell whether the deposition preparation took five hours and the call took half an hour, or the other way around.

Why guidelines prohibit or limit it

Outside counsel guidelines set how time must be recorded. Some prohibit block billing and ask the firm to list each task as its own entry. Others limit it and set the conditions under which a combined entry is allowed. The reason is the same in both cases: an invoice reviewer can only question what the invoice shows.

Several things hang on the split between tasks.

What a reviewer can and cannot tell from a block-billed line

From the line you can tell who billed it, on what date, at what rate, and the total. You can check that the hours multiplied by the rate equal the amount, and that the person is on your approved list.

You cannot tell how the hours divided among the tasks. You cannot tell whether one of the tasks was billable at all, or whether the total is reasonable for each task. You can only decide whether the total looks reasonable for the combined description, which is a limited test.

When your guidelines prohibit or limit block billing, the practical step is to return the invoice, or hold the invoice, and ask the firm to split the entry into its tasks with the time for each. Say which entry, and say what you need. "Please split the 6.5 hour entry on March 12 into its tasks, with the time for each" gives the firm something to do. "Please review your billing" does not.

What line-by-line review misses even when every line is clean

Suppose you read every line on an invoice and none of them is block billed, none is over rate and none is excluded. That tells you each line is acceptable. It does not tell you whether the invoice is acceptable.

What is missing is the shape of the work across lines. One piece of work, such as document review or a single motion, can run to many small, correct entries over several weeks. Each entry is clean. Together they can be far more hours than the matter calls for. The lines for that work are scattered through a list sorted by date, so you read each one and never see the total.

The staffing mix has the same problem. Each line shows one person. Whether one person carries most of the hours in a workstream, or whether partner time is going into work that suits an associate, shows up when you add the lines up by piece of work.

That is what grouping the lines into workstreams shows. How to read an outside counsel invoice by workstream gives the reading order: the total for each workstream, then the hours and people in the one that looks wrong, then the lines.

How LegalOperator checks the lines

LegalOperator groups the lines into workstreams and checks each against your rates, approved timekeepers and excluded charges. A person decides.

Common questions

What is block billing on an outside counsel invoice?

Block billing is one time entry that lists several tasks under a single total. A line that reads "prepare for deposition, review documents, call with client: 6.5 hours" is block billed. You can see the total, but not how the time divided among the tasks.

Why do outside counsel guidelines prohibit or limit block billing?

A block-billed entry hides how long each task took, so you cannot judge whether any one task was reasonable, billed at the right rate or billable at all. Some guidelines prohibit it and ask the firm to list each task as its own entry. Others limit it and set the conditions under which a combined entry is allowed.

What does line-by-line invoice review miss?

It misses the shape of the work across lines. Every line can be clean while one piece of work takes far more hours than the matter calls for, or the staffing mix is wrong. Grouping lines into workstreams shows that, which is covered in how to read an invoice by workstream.

Craig Raeburn

Craig Raeburn

Co-founder of LegalOperator. Has worked in legal technology since 1991. Ran customer success, product and sales at several legal technology vendors, from TyMetrix to SimpleLegal.

See your own invoices checked this way

Send three recent invoices to the 3-Invoice Pilot. They come back coded, grouped into workstreams and checked against your guidelines in one business day. No charge, nothing to install, nothing changes in your current tool.

Start the 3-Invoice Pilot