← Back to Blog

Legal E-Billing RFP Questions: Ten to Ask Every Vendor

How to evaluate legal e-billing software: the same ten questions for every vendor, why each one matters and what a good answer sounds like.

By , Co-founder, LegalOperator ·

To evaluate legal e-billing software, ask every vendor the same ten questions, in writing, in the same order, and ask each one to show its answers on your own invoices. Each has one paragraph on why it matters and what a good answer sounds like, then how LegalOperator answers in one sentence. Paste the list into your RFP as it is.

The ten questions

  1. Which invoice formats do you accept, and what happens to one you cannot read?
  2. How does each line get a UTBMS code, and who can change it?
  3. How are our guidelines and fee arrangements enforced on each line?
  4. Who approves an invoice, and how do holds and returns work?
  5. How do accruals work?
  6. How are budgets set, and what do they do?
  7. What reaches the General Counsel and CFO, and what exports to AP?
  8. What audit and security evidence can you show, and is our data used to train AI?
  9. What does the contract say about cancellation and price changes?
  10. What can we take with us if we leave, and when is our data deleted?

How to use the list

Send all ten at once and ask for written answers, each with the page or clause that states it. Decide before you send the list which answers are gates and which are weights, and mark an answer weak if it cannot be shown or written down.

1. Which invoice formats do you accept, and what happens to one you cannot read?

Firms do not all bill the same way. Some send LEDES files from their own billing systems and others send a PDF. Ask which formats the system takes, because every format it does not take becomes work for the firms or for your team. A good answer names both formats and says how a firm submits: through a portal, or by your team uploading on the firm’s behalf. It also says what happens to a file the system cannot read, such as a scanned PDF with no selectable text, instead of leaving you to find out on the first invoice.

LegalOperator: LEDES or PDF with selectable text, submitted by firms through a vendor portal or uploaded by you, and scanned image-only PDFs are not read.

2. How does each line get a UTBMS code, and who can change it?

UTBMS codes classify each line of an invoice as a task, an activity or an expense. Spend reporting by type of work depends on them. Ask whether the code on each line comes from the firm’s bill, from the software or from a person, and whether the system shows which. Ask what happens when the firm sent a code and the software disagrees. A good answer lets a person change any code, shows the change before it applies and leaves no line uncoded.

LegalOperator: The code is taken from the firm’s bill or assigned by AI when it is missing, and a person can set or clear it on any line after a preview and confirmation.

3. How are our guidelines and fee arrangements enforced on each line?

Ask whether every line is checked against your guidelines or only a sample, and what is checked on each line: approved rates, approved timekeepers, excluded charges and agreed fee arrangements such as a fixed fee or a cap. Ask where the rules live, who sets them up and who changes them. Ask what the reviewer sees when a line breaks a rule. A good answer shows a flagged line next to the rule that flagged it, in words your team can read, and says a person decides what to do about it.

LegalOperator: Every line is checked against your rates, approved timekeepers and excluded charges, and against the fee arrangement set on the matter.

4. Who approves an invoice, and how do holds and returns work?

Approval is where cost control becomes a decision, so ask who makes it. Ask who can approve, what a hold does, what a return does and what the firm sees when an invoice comes back. Ask how a corrected invoice re-enters the process. A good answer names a person on your team as the approver, sends a returned invoice to the firm with a specific reason and states that software does not reduce or pay an invoice without a person deciding.

LegalOperator: A person on your team approves, holds or returns each invoice, and a returned invoice goes back to the firm with a specific reason.

5. How do accruals work?

Finance needs the cost of work done but not yet billed, and the firms are the only ones who know it. Ask how the vendor collects it: whether it asks each firm, how often, what a firm has to do to answer and who follows up with a firm that does not. Ask how the answers reach finance, by matter or only as one total. A good answer is a recurring request to the firms, with a roll-up finance can read by matter and by firm.

LegalOperator: Monthly accrual requests go to firms and roll up for finance by matter and by firm.

6. How are budgets set, and what do they do?

A budget helps when it sits on the matter and spend shows against it as invoices arrive. Ask what shapes a budget can take, such as a total, a monthly cap or an amount for one year. Ask how you create one and what happens when spend reaches it. Some teams want a warning and others want payment held, so ask which the vendor does and whether you choose. A good answer says plainly whether crossing a budget blocks an invoice.

LegalOperator: Budgets of several types are created by describing them in words, sit on the matter, show spend as invoices arrive and never block an invoice.

7. What reaches the General Counsel and CFO, and what exports to AP?

Reporting is how invoice work becomes something leadership reads. Ask to see the one report your General Counsel or CFO would read without help: spend by matter and by firm for a period, billed against approved. Ask whether it arrives on a schedule or someone builds it each month, and whether it stays fixed once it is published. Then ask what leaves the system for accounts payable: which system, which file and whether anyone re-keys it. A good answer shows both, using your own AP system’s name.

LegalOperator: Spend rolls up by matter and by firm, the Legal Ops Scorecard gives the General Counsel and CFO a one-page monthly view in the app or as an emailed PDF, and approved invoices export to your AP system.

8. What audit and security evidence can you show, and is our data used to train AI?

Ask for the audit report and its date, and for the most recent penetration test. Ask whether the audit is SOC 2 Type II, which covers a period of time, or a point-in-time report, and whether the report exists yet or is in progress. Ask in writing whether customer data trains AI models, by the vendor and by the AI providers it uses. A good answer gives you a document and a date. If an audit is still in progress, a good answer says so and gives the date the report is expected.

LegalOperator: SOC 2 Type II audit in observation with the report expected November 2026, and customer data is not used to train AI models, by LegalOperator or by the AI providers it uses (Trust Center).

9. What does the contract say about cancellation and price changes?

The contract sets what you pay and when that can change, so read it before you decide. Ask for the full agreement, not a summary: how you cancel, when and by how much the price can change without your written agreement, and which fees sit outside the subscription, such as implementation, integrations, support or extra users. Ask whether the price is published, so you can budget before the first call. A good answer is written in the contract in plain words.

LegalOperator: No lock-in and no automatic price increases, with Intake and Full Suite prices published on the pricing page.

10. What can we take with us if we leave, and when is our data deleted?

Settle this before you sign, when you still have leverage. Ask which records you can export: firms with rates and approved timekeepers, matters with budgets and fee arrangements, invoice history with line items and codes, guidelines and accruals. Ask in which formats, who prepares the export, how long it takes after a written request and whether there is a fee. Ask when your data is deleted afterward and whether backups follow a different schedule. Ask also what it costs to load your history into the new system and who does the work. A good answer is in the contract, not in a sales email. The renewal and exit checklist goes through each of these in more detail.

LegalOperator: Pilot data is deleted from the app after 30 days and backups expire on their normal schedule, and one-time Full Suite setup covers account setup, standard integrations, basic admin training and loading your historical data.

Test the answers on your own invoices

Written answers tell you what a vendor will say. A demo on sample data shows how a product is meant to work. Your own invoices tell you what the system does. Take three recent invoices your current tool has already processed, run them through each vendor you are considering and put the results side by side. The same approach works at renewal: keep the current tool as it is, and compare.

LegalOperator’s 3-Invoice Pilot works this way. You send three recent invoices, LEDES or PDF. Within one business day they come back coded, grouped into workstreams and checked against your guidelines. There is no charge, nothing to install and nothing changes in your current tool.

Common questions about legal e-billing RFPs

How do you evaluate legal e-billing software?

Ask every vendor the same ten questions in writing, and ask each to show its answers on your own invoices. The questions cover invoice formats, coding, guideline checks, approvals, accruals, budgets, reporting and AP export, security, contract terms and data export at exit. Score the answers side by side before any demo.

How can I test a legal e-billing vendor before I commit?

Send the vendor three recent invoices your current tool has already processed and compare the results line by line. LegalOperator’s 3-Invoice Pilot does this at no charge, with nothing to install and no change to your current tool.

Craig Raeburn

Craig Raeburn

Co-founder of LegalOperator. Has worked in legal technology since 1991. Ran customer success, product and sales at several legal technology vendors, from TyMetrix to SimpleLegal.

Send us three invoices

No charge. One business day. Nothing changes in your current tool.

Start the 3-Invoice Pilot